Just realised I've been recommending drugstore and possibly animal tested products to someone who mentioned they've been using vegan makeup. *V8 facepalm*
(Right when I found a
non-stinging mask too.)
If you like cruelty free makeup and skincare I'd look into companies like the Body Shop and Lush. If their makeup isn't pale enough you could try Urban Decay, which is also cruelty free but has more alternative shades.
There's also
Fyrinnae, but I've heard sometimes mineral makeup bases can be shiny/cakey and highlight irregularities. YMMV. Have a squiz at the whole thing though because the eyeshadows look awesome.