Perhaps this dubious fellow believes that any item of furniture which can be ordered with black leather upholstery qualifies as goth? How very misguided. On the bright side, however, I rather assume that he shall not linger here.
I am currently in university (still living with my parents) and will have to get my own appartement/house in a few years and am wondering about what you have found so far for goth-inclined furniture? I bought all the edland collection form IKEA which has a pretty victorian-esque flair to it and bought a great gothic queen anne sofa from chesterfields... I'm ok with the bedroom and living room but have you found something for the other rooms?