Where Standeth Ye?
 

Rozz or Valor? And of course, Why?

I'm sure it's been done, so stfu.

If you have to ask who then gtfo.

Valor. He sings about more shit I'd rather hear about.

Rozz, cause Valor is a no talent hack.

Valor.

As much as I like Rozz and his intelligence and sensitivity and all that passionate artistic crap Valor simply had the better voice.

Since when?

For music, I prefer Rozz. I just like the sound and atmosphere more than CD's post-Rozz stuff.

For personal qualities, though, it's Valor, because he hasn't killed himself like a dumb shit.

I prefer ol' Mr. Williams. I've never cared for Valor. It borders on hatred, but I wouldn't go quite that far.

I love Rozz's voice. And I tend to agree with what Lochnar said.

Valor's crew has produced a larger amount of quality tracks, but the few from Rozz kick enough ass to make up the difference.

Christian Death sucks.

This poll fails.

Actually, there was a time when I would have agreed with that. I think it took me longer to appreciate Christian Death than any of the other goth bands I've ever liked. But then, I've always favored the British goth scene over anything out of CA just like I favor the British punk scene over anything out of CA.

So basically what he means is that yer taste is not refined.

JWell to be fair, I hate most goth bands other than Bauhaus and Fields.

That's quite an arbitrary opinion, no?

Since I have my opinion and you have yours. END.

Fuck `em both. Sitting down.

I actually think that the best incarnation of Christian Death was the one with Rozz, Valor, Gitane DeMone and David Glass.

That's a safe answer.

For the most part I agree. Anything after Rozz was no longer a member kinda irks me to listen to. I'm not sure if that just because I hold a grudge against Valor, or because his voice actually bothers me. I think it's the latter.

I just don't lke them clinging to the name.

No shit teeth, I mean when do you feels Valor started to be a no talent hack. Was he a no talent hack when he made those two records with Rozz too or afterwards when Rozz pussied out on that tour and left the band?

I respect your opinion. Just kidding.

Why? Rozz only made one real record without Valor. Rozz just claimed the name when he found out Cleopatra would cut him a check for heroin money. Valor kept it so he wouldn't let down the fans in Europe. Also why he lied and said Rozz died. But faking someone elses death is way goth anyway.

I love them both, but :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LzkA9b2foQ

has to be one of my favorite songs, so I guess Valor.

I also say Christian Death sucks. But Shadow Project rocks, and that's a Rozz thing, so I go for Rozz.

I bet you can't explain why you like Shadow Project but not Christian Death without resorting to one of the following crutches:

a. It's just mai opinion!
b. B/c Shadow Project isn't trendy and I am TRUGoth.
c. My musical taste is shit.

Methinks you will admit to A but nae the rest.

Well, when it comes to music, poetry, fiction, movies, any other form of art, opinion is really all that matters...